[TL;DR]
- The legacy Web3 onboarding stack relied on EOA-based wallets and WalletConnect, resulting in a complex UX and high development burdens.
- The next-generation onboarding stack, based on ERC-4337, addresses fundamental Web3 UX issues through smart accounts, gasless transactions, and account recovery.
- The emergence of embedded wallets and integrated development environments allows Web3 to conceal complex technical processes while preserving its core decentralization values.
1. The Current State of Web3 Onboarding
1.1 User Experience Issues in the Legacy Stack
As the Web3 ecosystem grows rapidly, innovative decentralized services continue to emerge. From DeFi protocols to NFT marketplaces, GameFi, and SocialFi, diverse services are delivering new value to users. However, despite these innovations, most Web3 services still impose an overly complex and difficult onboarding process on users.
Examining the legacy onboarding approach adopted by most Web3 services today, users must go through multiple complicated steps to start using a service. First, they need to find and install a self-custodial wallet like MetaMask from the Chrome Web Store or app store. At this stage, users often struggle to decide which wallet to choose, as identifying a secure and reliable option among numerous alternatives is a daunting task for beginners.
Once the wallet is installed, even more complexity awaits. Users must securely store a randomly generated 12–24-word seed phrase, knowing that losing it means losing access to all their assets forever. After setting up the seed phrase, they must create a wallet password and sometimes go through additional security verification steps.
Only after completing these tedious setup procedures can users finally access a Web3 service. But even then, the inconvenience continues. To interact with a service, users must constantly click the "Connect Wallet" button and manually approve transactions for nearly every action within the platform. This is akin to undergoing an authentication process every time you visit a website and approving a pop-up for every click.
For crypto-native users, these steps might feel routine, as they understand that such complexities are necessary for decentralization and asset security. However, for general users transitioning from Web2, this is an excessively complicated and burdensome experience. They are accustomed to logging in with Google or Facebook and seamlessly using services through intuitive interfaces. The convoluted Web3 onboarding process serves as a significant barrier to adoption for these users.
1.2 The Inconvenient Truth About “Connect Wallet”
The problems with the "Connect Wallet" onboarding method extend beyond just a complicated process. This approach creates several structural issues that hinder the usability and accessibility of Web3 services.
First, users must understand technical concepts such as seed phrases, gas fees, transactions, and blockchain addresses. These terms are unfamiliar and difficult to grasp for most users. The concept of gas fees, in particular, is a major source of confusion. The need to pay a separate fee for each transaction, with fluctuating costs depending on network conditions, introduces uncertainty for users.
Second, self-custodial wallets place the entire security responsibility on users. From managing seed phrases to approving transactions, a single mistake can result in the permanent loss of assets. Unlike centralized services that offer password resets and customer support, Web3 lacks these safety nets, forcing users to remain constantly cautious.
Third, the wallet connection process is often unstable and inefficient. Users frequently need to reconnect their wallets for the same service, and unexpected disconnections are common. This issue is particularly problematic on mobile devices, where linking browser extension wallets with mobile apps is cumbersome, significantly reducing cross-platform usability.
1.3 High Entry Barriers and User Drop-Off Rates
The complexity of the onboarding process and usability issues inevitably lead to high user drop-off rates. Data shows that many Web3 services lose a substantial number of potential users during the initial onboarding phase.
The wallet installation and setup process is the biggest source of user attrition. Many users abandon the process due to the complexity of setup and the burden of managing seed phrases. This problem is even more pronounced on mobile devices, where users expect an immediate and seamless experience.
Lack of understanding about gas fees also contributes to drop-off rates. Users find it difficult to accept the idea of paying a fee for every transaction. During periods of high gas fees, many users simply give up on using the service. Additionally, the need to purchase cryptocurrency separately and store it in the wallet to cover gas fees adds an extra layer of inconvenience.
Irrecoverable mistakes further discourage active participation. In Web2 services, users can rely on customer support to resolve mistakes. In Web3, however, sending assets to the wrong address or approving an unintended transaction is irreversible. This risk makes users hesitant to engage fully with Web3 services.
The usability gap compared to traditional Web2 services is another major issue. Users are accustomed to smooth and intuitive experiences provided by Google and Facebook. Compared to these platforms, current Web3 services lag significantly in usability. Complicated authentication steps, unstable connections, and slow processing create a negative impression of Web3.
These problems present significant obstacles to Web3’s mass adoption. Despite the presence of innovative technologies and services, complex onboarding and usability challenges prevent many potential users from entering the Web3 ecosystem. This highlights the urgent need for a next-generation onboarding solution.
2. The Limitations of the Legacy Onboarding Stack
2.1 The Limitations of MetaMask and WalletConnect-Based Infrastructure
The legacy onboarding stack, built around MetaMask and WalletConnect, has formed the foundation of the Web3 ecosystem. It became the de facto standard from Web3’s early days, with most dApps designed around this structure. MetaMask, an EOA (Externally Owned Account)-based browser extension, has been the most widely used wallet in the Web3 ecosystem.
WalletConnect played a crucial role in linking wallets with dApps, especially enabling mobile users to interact with desktop dApps via QR codes or deep links. While this method was innovative at the time, it has since revealed several fundamental limitations as Web3 evolved.
The biggest issue is that EOA-based wallets rely entirely on a single private key, leading to severe security and usability weaknesses. If the private key is exposed, all assets are lost. Unlike traditional web services, Web3 lacks standard security features like account recovery or password resets.
From a usability perspective, the need to manually sign every transaction significantly hampers the user experience. In DeFi, for instance, even a simple token swap requires at least two signatures—one for token approval and another for executing the swap.
The mobile experience is particularly cumbersome. WalletConnect connections are often unstable, requiring inconvenient QR code scans or app switching. These inefficiencies clash with the growing trend of mobile-first digital interactions.
2.2 Complex Development Environment and Integration Challenges
Developing a dApp based on the legacy stack poses significant challenges for developers. Beyond writing smart contracts and front-end code, they must build and maintain complex Web3 infrastructure, akin to re-implementing fundamental web protocols from scratch.
Wallet integration, in particular, is a major hurdle. While tools like Web3Modal and WalletConnect offer basic connectivity, developers must handle various wallet implementations and unique exceptions. Mobile integration further increases complexity, requiring deep-link handling, app switching, and state synchronization.
Transaction processing is another major challenge. Due to blockchain’s asynchronous nature, developers must manage transaction states, handle failures, optimize gas fees, and provide real-time user feedback.
Cross-chain functionality introduces even greater complexity. Developers must synchronize states across different chains, implement bridge protocols, and navigate the unique constraints of each blockchain.
The security burden is also significant. Even minor security oversights can lead to immediate asset loss, requiring thorough validation of every component, from signature verification to transaction security.
This complexity raises development barriers, increases costs, and heightens the risk of bugs and vulnerabilities. Developers spend excessive time on infrastructure rather than focusing on core service innovation, slowing Web3’s evolution and hindering user experience improvements.
2.3 Increasing Complexity Over Time
The complexity of the legacy Web3 stack continues to grow. As new blockchains emerge, new wallet solutions are developed, and new standards are proposed, the complexity that developers must manage keeps increasing.
For Web3 to scale and reach mass adoption, it must overcome these fundamental challenges. The current limitations of the legacy onboarding stack emphasize the need for a next-generation onboarding solution.
3. The Rise of the Next-Generation Onboarding Stack
3.1 The Emergence of Hybrid Login
Despite its revolutionary potential, Web3 has long struggled with onboarding complexity. To solve this, a new approach called hybrid login has emerged.
The core idea behind hybrid login is user choice. Instead of forcing users through a complex wallet setup, they can start with a familiar Google or Apple account. Registering via email and setting a password is already an intuitive experience for most users.
This convenience is enabled by Multi-Party Computation (MPC) technology. Unlike the traditional approach, where users must manage a private key, MPC splits the key into multiple pieces and stores them securely. For example, part of the key is stored on the user’s device, while another part is held by the service provider. When a transaction is needed, these fragments work together to generate a secure signature.
The biggest advantage of this method is flexibility. Users can start with social login and, when ready, transition to full self-custody. Once they gain a deeper understanding of blockchain and wallets, they can seamlessly shift to managing their own keys.
This model also strikes a balance between security and convenience. Users don’t need to manually manage a 24-word seed phrase, but they also don’t hand over complete control to a centralized entity. MPC ensures that users retain ownership of their assets while preventing any single entity from having full control.
3.2 The Rise of Smart Accounts and Web3 Standards Evolution
Efforts to improve Web3’s poor user experience have accelerated with the introduction of ERC-4337, which introduces account abstraction. This standard has sparked ongoing innovations, shaping the direction of the Web3 ecosystem.
The biggest transformation brought by smart accounts is flexibility. Unlike traditional EOA wallets, which rely on a single key, smart accounts allow programmable custom security settings. Users can implement rules such as daily withdrawal limits or requiring extra confirmations for high-value transactions. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for businesses and DAOs, enabling multi-signature approvals and backup account designations.
Another major shift is how transaction fees are handled. With the introduction of Paymasters, service providers can cover gas fees for users. This makes Web3 interactions as seamless as using a credit card at a café. In NFT marketplaces and blockchain games, where frequent transactions occur, this feature greatly enhances the user experience by removing the need to worry about small transaction fees.
The bundling feature further refines user interactions. Previously, purchasing an NFT required two separate transactions—one for token approval and another for the actual purchase. With smart accounts, multiple steps can be bundled into a single transaction, reducing costs and improving efficiency.
Account recovery mechanisms have also improved significantly. Users are no longer at risk of permanently losing access to their assets due to a lost private key. Social recovery mechanisms allow users to regain access with the help of trusted contacts, while alternative authentication methods like hardware wallets and biometric verification provide additional security layers.
Another game-changer is session keys, which streamline interactions in games and DeFi applications. Instead of requiring wallet approvals for every action, users can grant limited permissions for a specific session. This removes the frustration of constant confirmations, making services feel much smoother.
The Web3 ecosystem continues to push new standards beyond ERC-4337. NFT-based account systems, enhanced security rules, and more efficient account management methods are actively being developed through Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs). This ongoing innovation is making Web3 services more mature and user-friendly.
3.3 Embedded Wallets: The Key to Next-Gen Onboarding
The rise of Wallet-as-a-Service (WaaS) is revolutionizing Web3 onboarding. Previously, users had to install external wallets like MetaMask or Rainbow before connecting to a service. Embedded wallets eliminate this unnecessary friction, seamlessly integrating wallet functionality within the service itself.
The core principle of embedded wallets is a progressive user experience. Users start with email or social login, and Web3 functionality activates only when needed. For example, an NFT marketplace user can casually browse NFTs and purchase one with a credit card. Behind the scenes, a wallet is automatically created, and the NFT is transferred—all without the user having to manage a wallet.
One standout feature is the synergy with smart accounts. Embedded wallets leverage ERC-4337-based smart accounts to enable gasless transactions, batch processing, and social recovery. This opens up possibilities beyond simple wallets. For instance, a game can automate transactions when specific conditions are met, and complex DeFi interactions can be streamlined into a single approval.
Integration with existing services has also become smoother. Large platforms are now embedding custom wallets, allowing millions of users to enter Web3 effortlessly. Social media platforms can facilitate digital asset transactions, and games can record in-game items on the blockchain, increasing real-world use cases for Web3.
This innovation is making Web3 a natural part of daily life, hiding its technical complexity while preserving decentralization.
3.4 The Evolution of Integrated Development Environments for Developers
One of the most significant impacts of next-gen onboarding stacks is how they improve the developer experience. Previously, developers had to invest substantial time in wallet integration and infrastructure maintenance, diverting attention from core innovations. New developer tools are now transforming this landscape.
Platforms like WEPIN, Dynamic, and Privy are leading this change, offering comprehensive solutions beyond basic wallet connectivity. Developers can now implement social login, embedded wallets, and gas fee sponsorship with just a few lines of code.
A major advantage of these tools is their simplified development process. Developers no longer need to handle the intricacies of multiple wallets or different blockchain implementations. These platforms abstract away the complexity, allowing developers to focus on building services. For example, cross-chain transactions can be implemented easily using pre-built APIs, eliminating the need to understand each blockchain’s unique quirks.
Troubleshooting has also become much easier. In the past, identifying transaction failures or wallet connection issues was challenging. Now, detailed error logs, real-time monitoring, and debugging tools help developers quickly diagnose and resolve problems.
Additionally, admin dashboards for managing settings provide further flexibility. Developers can add new blockchains or integrate additional wallets without modifying the code, allowing them to keep pace with the rapidly evolving Web3 landscape.
User analytics tools have also improved, giving developers insights into user behavior and helping them optimize onboarding flows. Data-driven decisions are now possible, leading to continuous service improvements.
These advancements do more than just speed up development—they enhance the overall quality of Web3 services. By removing barriers and enabling developers to focus on innovation, the Web3 ecosystem is becoming more efficient and user-friendly.
4. Conclusion: A New Era of Web3 Onboarding
While the Web3 ecosystem has made tremendous technological progress in recent years, complex user experiences have remained a major barrier to mass adoption. However, with the rise of the next-generation onboarding stack, these limitations are finally being addressed.
Hybrid login, smart accounts, and embedded wallets have significantly lowered Web3’s entry barriers, allowing users to engage with Web3 services without struggling with complex technical concepts. Developers, too, can now leverage robust infrastructure tools, freeing them to focus on creating better user experiences.
ERC-4337 and ongoing standardization efforts are accelerating the evolution of Web3. Account abstraction, gasless transactions, and social recovery features are transforming Web3 into a technology that is not only powerful but also intuitive and secure.
Ultimately, Web3’s success depends on how many people can truly benefit from its innovations. The next-generation onboarding stack represents a significant step toward this goal. As innovation continues, Web3 will no longer be seen as a niche technology but rather a natural part of everyday digital experiences.
[WEPIN Wallet SNS Channels]
